Book Jacket

 

rank  Editors Pick
word count 61905
date submitted 07.02.2012
date updated 02.11.2012
genres: Fiction, Fantasy, Young Adult
classification: moderate
complete

Jinger Barley and The Murkle Moon

Lucy Middlemass

Bloody moons. They never do what you want and this one is no different.

 

Why would anyone write a story about the last baby of the previous millennium?

Jinger’s birth date gave her the feeling that she was old when she was a little girl; that she really belonged to a time in which she had barely lived. Her twin was new and young, the inaugural child of the silver new year, whereas Jinger was a lingering remnant of the instantly unfashionable thousand years before.

Sent up to school in Murkle, home of the famous wandering Moon, Jinger wants to fit in with the other pupils so much she even tries to copy their accent. But people in Murkle seem to have been waiting for her to arrive, one of them for more than a hundred years.

 
rate the book

to rate this book please Register or Login

 

tags

astronomy, boarding school, fantasy, fiction, humour, magic, teen

on 190 watchlists

488 comments

 

Text Size

Text Colour

Chapters

37

report abuse

Chapter Thirty Six

 

“I have another theory, Ms Flapp,” Arthur said, not opening his eyes and stretching his legs towards the warmth of the fire.

    Ms Flapp had been sure the ancient astronomer was asleep. He had been sitting back in the armchair in his living room all morning. Ms Flapp turned away from her laptop almost as glad of the distraction as she was keen to hear what Arthur had to say. “Go on then. Is it about the Moon?” she said eagerly.

    “Yes. So you’d better get ready to put the kettle on because this time it’s, as you might say… a doozy!” Arthur exclaimed, sounding pleased with himself for using a young person’s word.

    Ms Flapp was pretty sure she would never say that but she smiled and waited for him to carry on.

    “The Moon moved on Millennium Eve, even though it was forbidden from moving ever since the near-miss,” Arthur recapped.

    “Yes,” Ms Flapp interjected helpfully.

    “And then I reported it and it’s been in a sulk ever since. I suppose whoever was supposed to be watching it was out revelling.“ Arthur said the last word as though it was a mysterious activity that only a very modern person indeed would think of indulging in on a New Year’s Eve. “The first time I saw it move out of its pattern like that was to save May Bloom’s life.” He did not open his eyes and Ms Flapp knew when he did, it would add considerable drama to whatever point it coincided with.

    “That’s right,” Ms Flapp confirmed. “But I thought you’d decided that the only connection between the two events was you?”

    “Almost the only connection! I’ve been working on a theory that there is someone else too.”

    This was a surprise to Ms Flapp but she did not say so. It did not look like Arthur had been working on anything recently. Mostly he had looked like he had been recovering from a stab wound in hospital followed by a long stretch in the armchair by the fire.

    “Okay…” she said hesitantly.

    “The other connection is Jinger Barley!” he declared, suddenly flinging open his eyes and grinning as though he had just thought of the best name for a planet ever.

    “Jinger? You are going to have to explain that to me, Arthur. I know a lot has been said about Jinger recently. That Woodcutter and the woman who attacked us over Christmas both wanted to kill her so she couldn’t destroy Murkle, but what has she got to do with the Moon?” she asked. Clearly her emails were going to remain unread for some time.

    “Ah! It is more what the Moon had to do with Jinger! I had been thinking in all the wrong places about this. We know now that Jinger was born on Millennium Eve and that being born on an eve is what ‘The Murkle Truth’ says is important.”

    Ms Flapp nodded her head.

    “Goliath Swat‘s book is in the library at the school. Anyone can read it. Malcolm Culpin read it over one Christmas when he was a boy,” Arthur said.

    “Do you think that‘s why he became a Woodcutter?” Ms Flapp asked.

    “Yes. He believed that Jinger would destroy Murkle because of what he learnt in the book. He wanted to make everyone a wolf, and once Jinger was dead, he thought everyone would be able to change. He wanted to make up for his father rejecting him because he couldn’t change himself.”

    “Doesn’t the legend say that the child who is born on the eve will be evil?”

    “The book says that the child will have great power but I don‘t think in Jinger‘s case that means evil. My abilities were evident even when I was a boy and Jinger is far too sweet a girl to be evil. As you know I was born on New Year’s Eve 1899. I can remember everything and talk to the Moon.”

    “Don‘t forget about the longevity too, Arthur!” Ms Flapp exclaimed.

    Arthur smiled. “I haven’t destroyed Murkle, and I’m not really planning to. The power isn’t necessarily evil. It‘s reasonable to conclude that her powers will be greater than mine because she was born on a more important Eve. Therefore, if she was evil, I would expect her to be fairly bad already. The book only says she will decide Murkle’s fate and no one really knows what that might mean.”

    Ms Flapp took this in. It made some sense. If Arthur’s birthday had made him special, Jinger’s must have made her incredible. Then Ms Flapp realised Arthur could not have finished his explanation. “So what does this have to do with the Moon, then?”

    “Ah! That is the other interesting question. I took the very unscientific leap of assuming that there are no coincidences. The Moon moved and shone on Brink Stenton. Its beam highlighted just one house and I think I know what was happening in there that night. I believe Jinger Barley, my granddaughter, was being born. For some reason, I think the Moon moved to show someone where that was. I haven’t talked to her father about this yet, but I believe someone needed to know where that house was to make sure Jinger came into the world safely.”

    Ms Flapp could feel the urge to get up and get the best biscuits from the kitchen. Arthur’s theory was good but he had forgotten something.

    “What about May Bloom? Why did the Moon move to save her?” she asked gently.

    “You cannot possibly think I had forgotten about that!” Arthur said laughing. “I might be a very old man, Ms Flapp, but I do not forget. That night was… well, this is embarrassing. That night was the night we um… created Julia. So May Bloom had to be saved so she could have our daughter.”

    Ms Flapp was not shocked by this part of the revelation. She had known Arthur was not married to Jinger’s grandmother. Ms Flapp thought about Arthur’s theory for a while. The Moon had left its pattern to save first Jinger’s grandmother from the circling wolves on the school field, and then Jinger when she was being born on Millennium Eve. That did seem to make sense. Because of her birth date, Jinger’s life was important enough to Murkle for the Moon to risk upsetting a whole town of people by breaking its routine.

    “And then there was what happened in the observatory,” Arthur said carefully, not wanting to upset his friend by reminding her of that event.

    “With the Moon again?” she asked, beginning to see where Arthur was going with this.

    “Yes. There wasn’t much it could do but it showed up, filling the sky. I don’t know if the boy would have got such a good hold if the Woodcutter had not been dazzled by the sudden light. We’ll never know, I suppose, but it might just have helped save our Jinger Barley again.” This was Arthur’s triumphant piece of proof.

    So there was only one question left. Arthur looked expectant and Ms Flapp did not know whether this was because he was anticipating her saying his theory was wonderful or just wrong. Maybe he was just wondering about the left over mince pies in the kitchen.

    “Arthur, you do know you have two granddaughters, don’t you? Jinger is a twin. Her sister Jessica, goes to Brink Stenton Sports and Community College,” Ms Flapp said eying the kettle through the hatch.

    “Yes, of course I know that. But Jessica was born on the other side of midnight. She might have been a true Millennium baby but I‘m afraid that doesn‘t get you any extra powers in Murkle!”

Chapters

37

report abuse

To leave comments on this or any book please Register or Login

subscribe to comments for this book
HarperCollins Wrote

Twins Jessica and Jinger Barley were born minutes apart either side of the new millennium, and are as different as twins can be. Jinger, always sidelined compared to her “pretty” twin, starts at a new school in Murkle, which is famed for having its own moon. Whilst 113-year-old Arthur Oldham works to discover why this moon sometimes wanders, Jinger is trying to fit in at her school, but finds the lessons and schedule bizarre – not to mention the fact that students periodically leave to “join the pack” at the Upper School.

I found this a great read – quirky and fun – and thoroughly enjoyed discovering what on earth was going on at Murkle Manor School. Jinger is a very sympathetic character, and her anxieties about fitting in at a new school were well wrought – I think we can all empathise with those worries! Her father is similarly very likeable, and his determination to run a souvenir shop in a town where no tourists come is beautifully crafted. In fact, the characterisation in general is very strong – Arthur, Jessica, Tabs and Felix also jump off the page. I’d have liked to see a little more on Dorothy, however, to flesh her out a little.

The writing is strong, and the only criticism I have on this front is that some of the flashbacks lead to a little confusion, and perhaps need moving around. For example, the scene where Jinger receives the parcel from Helen leads to a lovely cliffhanger – what’s in it?! – but then the chronology became a little confusing for me, and it wasn’t clear what she had been sent for quite some time. I found myself having to flick back and forth to find out what was happening. Throughout the book there are plenty of twists and turns, which kept my attention very effectively, though I felt that some things perhaps needed to be revealed or alluded to earlier. In particular, I think the book would benefit from mentioning the prophecy and the Woodcutters earlier, as they become such an important part of the plot and yet are only first mentioned quite late.

This is a good novel, and I think it could have appeal within this age group due to its depictions of sibling rivalry, the terrors of starting a new school, and the wish to grow up quickly. However, there were a couple of plot points I thought might be out of sync with the readership the rest of the book seemed aimed at. Dorothy turns out to be very cruel and bloodthirsty indeed, particularly her role in the death of Jinger’s mother (and Caroline, though it passed me by until a second reading that Dorothy was therefore responsible for her daughter’s death too). Perhaps this was just because I found her one of the less well-rounded characters, and so her actions seemed particularly motiveless and pitiless – it wasn’t apparent to me why she was so concerned about the prophecy, and at the end I was still unclear what was in the bottle she was so keen to find. I also found the explanation of why the Murkle moon moves on the night Arthur is with May on the field a little ‘adult’, however vague, and I think May could need to be saved because of Julia without that having to be the night they, in the words of Arthur, “created her”.

I have to confess that, having thoroughly enjoyed the book so far, I was a little disappointed with the ending. The twist around the twins’ birth wasn’t entirely necessary, and to me it made the conclusion to the story rather frustrating, as it raised more questions than answers. I would have also liked to learn why Dorothy did what she did. That said, I hope there will be a sequel, as I am keen to know how the prophecy will be fulfilled! There’s something here, but it’s just not quite there yet.

Trailer Bride wrote 274 days ago

A wonderful and beautifully written, occasionally heartrending story, full of quirk and charm and whimsy, and laced with hidden depths, Jinger Barley is an Alt-Potter for those teenagers of all ages who know that life comes in more than fifty shades of grey.

Or, to put it another way, this book effing rocks.

benedict wrote 278 days ago

Chapter seven is still, in my opinion, the best thing on Authonomy.

It's absolute perfection and you should be very proud of your incredible book.

sincerely,

Benedict

CatherineM wrote 291 days ago

Lucy, you have quite spoiled me for returning all the reads I'm supposed to, and ruined me for reading anything that feels like work! Jinger is so perfect, and so enjoyable, I can't seem to make myself slog through any of the books I ought to be reading today. I am sure you have heard the obvious comparison before, but I feel like I did when I bought the first Harry Potter and didn't get anything productive done for the rest of the weekend. Bravo! Now, how am I going to clear a spot on my shelf? Hmmm...

Warmly,

Catherine Morgan
Nickel Ridge

mat012 wrote 293 days ago

Club Grimoire Review:

Perfection! Wonderfully written and instantly engaging with characters (both in the prologue and the first chapter) who leap off the pages and dance away with your time and imagination. It is written in the precisely perfect style for a young adult audience and puts my in mind of Terry Prachett's work for the YA market (which is a very good thing). I did not notice one single thing to nitpick over and whether that is due to the fact there is none or that I was so swept away it doesn't matter because the book is doing its job. I have high hopes of being able to proudly tell people that I read this before it was published.

High stars indeed!

Meagan

EllieMcG wrote 302 days ago

Club Grimoire:
I have nothing to add, because I believe it is perfect. In one chapter, I can say that it's clever, funny, and very well-written. I love this book, and want to see it on my real bookshelf.

Cecily Macintyre wrote 4 days ago

Great book - hoping HC and you are tweaking right now wit a view to pulbishing this.

Jimmy Window wrote 7 days ago

YARG review

chap 21 - has all the suspense needed. Nothing else to say.
chap 22 - didn't see that coming.
chap 23 - I like the way the moon helped Arthur here
chap 24 - now it get really interesting! And who Is the other woodcutter?

Can't say anything about this book except it's fantastic.

Jimmy

Jimmy Window wrote 15 days ago

YARG review

chap 17 - great backstory on Mrs. Flapp. They are getting closer to discovering who the person born on the EVE is.

chap 18 - the dialogue is done really well here.

chap 19 - poor Felix. you make us feel for him. He wants to change so bad tonight...I have a feeling he won't.

chap 20 - I didn't expect that ending...that was great!

Nothing I can say about this other than it's very good!

Nameless Pasta wrote 17 days ago

Hi Lucy!
I wish I am good as you. Wow. The storyline of your book is one of the most original I have read so far. The details were spectacular. Jessica and Jinger were presented very well. I can almost see this book hitting every book stands!
Best of luck!
Please, if you have spare time, do check out my book The Hunter Chronicles and tell me what you think about it. It's still unfinished though but I will gladly accept all kinds of comments. I hope you don't mind this request. I just thought I still need to learn a lot from people like you. Thanks!
Stay inspired! :)
~Princess

Jimmy Window wrote 22 days ago

YARG review
back for more

chap 14 - I liked Arthur's theory on why the moon moved. Looks like they may have found a connection to Jinger!

chap 15 - the 'W''s was a great idea. The ending is good too!

chap 16 - "No I'm not shocked," said Jinger, horribly shocked. - that was funny.
I liked this chapter because I found out a little about the wolves. I still can't get over how well Jinger is taking all this. You have a great hook at the end, too!

Great job!
Jimmy

Jimmy Window wrote 33 days ago

YARG review
back for chaps 11 - 13

chap 11:
'use this time usefully' - probably should change use or usefully to something else.
I was a bit surprised Jinger had no adverse reaction when Tabs mentioned werewolves. Did I miss something, or did Jinger already know (or suspect) about the students turning into wolves? This chapter did explain Felix's reaction to the silver necklace. I like when the explanation for something we read chapters earlier (something we couldn't possible understand then) is given.
chap 12:
not sure where all this fits in, but it's an interesting back story. The ending was quite sad.
chap 13:
'last night's stew?" - that was good!
I wonder reading this if the breeding experiments have some significance, other than to highlight Jinger's intellect. Wonder what's going on at the end of the chapter?

Still liking this

Jimmy Window wrote 40 days ago

YARG Review -
read chapters 8 - 10
chap 8 leaves one with questions throughout, but especially at the ending. I've never seen pajamas spelled pyjamas, though.
chap 9 has a great ending as well. Why does Felix hate the necklace?
chap 10 gives some interesting background on Arthur I really liked. Also the Murkle Moon stepping in to save May was good. Are these kids werewolves or something? Guess I'll have to keep reading to find out. The chapter again ends leaving us wanting to turn the page!

Still really like this story.
Jimmy

R.J.Gardham wrote 51 days ago

YARG review

Hello,

Read first 3 chapters and shall definitely get round to reading more! Loved the writing style, loved the subject.

Opening paragraph - 'much preferred a cup of tea.' The witty comparison sets up the chapter and lets me know I'm in for a treat - having read further I know this was correct. The style of writing is perfectly balanced between serious and whimsical - with an ample helping of humour lacing each line. Really enjoyable to read.
There are subtle allusions to more intelligent comedy - 'No, I'm Edward and she's Catherine,' - mixing up the sexes as well as the names of children by the aged man, a senior moment not made too big a deal of but just there in the background.

In Chapter I empathised with Jinger from the moment I first met her. This is well written via her interaction with her twin, all the more ironic because they are twins that they are described as 'opposites.'

First and second chapters introduce the Murkle Moon, which can apparently speak and wander, seamlessly into the body of the story, inviting further exploration. I really want to know what is special about this moon! The astronomy teachers and their discussion in Ch 3 provide some initial explanation into the night sky which throws light on this.

Ch3

Ms Flapp (appropriately named) is described inventively and in great detail particularly about her problem. This is quite original and a great character weakness not often heard of before. 'Lots of pupils would have a very hungry lunchtime,' - humourous consequence of her dithering!

Really great and I shall look forward to reading more.

Robert
Immortality of Ashes

Jimmy Window wrote 61 days ago

YARG review -
Back for more -
Chapter 5 -
I love the email to Arthur's grandddaughter about buying slippers from the TV screen
chapter 6 -
dusty-tasting glass of water. - nice!
...weird place full of unkempt teachers, choking pupils, and engraved beds - I like that
great ending to the chapter!
chapter 7 -
forever had other ideas - great line
I like the part about the standing excuse (and joke) of Douglas calling Julia to ask if there is anything she wants him to bring home from the souvenir shop.
I thought the ending of chap 6 was good - but chap 7 really ends with suspense! That was great.

No time to read more now, but I am on the edge of my seat. Who rammed them with the Land Rover and why?

Be back when I can,
Jimmy


Jimmy Window wrote 66 days ago

YARG review

Hi Lucy,

I read chapters 3 and 4. Chapter 4 was really nice. You brought to life the scene with the meat stuck in Felix's throat. I was squirmig. I could see Jinger sticking her hand down his throat and almost feel her trying to get her fringers around the lodged chunk. Yuk. That was well done! Nice way to end the chapter too. Chapter 4 was equally descriptive and disgusting when Felix coughed up the chunk and prompty stuffed it iback n his mouth.
Your descriptions of the girls sharing the room with Jinger are short and to the point. Something I could learn from! The last sentence in the chapter piques one's interest.

This book continues to be very good and is so well written.

I'll be back for more.
Jimmy

Jimmy Window wrote 72 days ago

YARG Review

hi Lucy,

After Lying About Sarah, I didn't know what to expect, but having read through chapter two, ths is another wonderful book.

Prologue -
Nice set up here. Very original. This guy isn't just talking to the moon (who talks back), he's talking to some 'other' moon. Curious as to what Arthur's job was - watching the Murkle Moon probably doesn't pay a lot. I have no idea why he's talking to the moon, or why it talks to him, but want to read on to find out. That's what a prologue should do! The changing millennium must mean something!

Chapter 1 -
"that idea began to stick as hard as a tiny shell on the side of a boat." - love this
You really did well at relating Jinger and Jessica as polar opposites.
Great ending to chapter 1.

Chapter 2 -
I love the way Ms. Flapp regards Arthur. The line "When Arthur returned to the school, the sky suddenly looked breathtaking, and Ms Flapps felt that she need not have bothered to look up before." is great.
The use of the tree when Ms Flapp was a girl to portray her inability to make decisions was brilliant.
Now the prologue comes into focus. I know why Arthur watched the Murkle Moon. It's still strange that the moon has feelings and when it gets hurt it reacts like a child (that's the way I saw it). But stange is good to me! I like that I've not read anything like this before.

This book is very different from Lying About Sarah, but your turn of phrase, clean editing, and impeccible style show through just the same. I prefer this book, because LAS is so heavy and despressing. Looks like you have the whole book here. I will chip away at it until I've read it all.

Jimmy

jessicaminor wrote 94 days ago

Yarg-

Lucy
wow this was very diffrent, i really enjoyed it. you have a great attention to detail. i also noticed i personally have difficulty with say diffrent charecters not the main ones but al the side charecters when i write, but you seem to be wonderful at it only thing in chapter 5 is the phrase chrismassed proper? i was unsure here it would be spent christmas with , but it may be the whole other country language thing again.

jessicaminor wrote 95 days ago

i really love the pitch on this one.. it looks great. i will comment on it when i get either a few chapters or all of it read...it's 4 a.m now so i better not read it yet....on watchlist though

Jacoba wrote 100 days ago

Hi Lucy,
I've read the first five chapters and I will be back for more. This is so well written, and a great read.
I loved the imagination in this, and all the characters names and quirks, Arthur is already a favourite. You have captured the voice needed for YA, and I think a wide range of ages in that category would enjoy this.
I laughed when Felix choked ...but didn't, and Tabs seems like such a nice character. You have captured the anxiety that must be felt joining a new school perfectly, Jinger reacts just like you would expect, meeting new people and adapting to her new environment. I liked her bed being under the slanting roof, a cosy place for her.
The descriptions are vivid but not overdone, and I your use of metaphors are spot on.
It has a Harry Potter feel, but is definitely its own story, so I see that as a good ... no great ... thing!!
I expect to see this published in the near future, I read a lot of literature in this category and this would certainly do well I'm sure. Great stuff.
Jx

Dr Hawkes wrote 106 days ago

A hugely enjoyable read with a likeable character in Jinger.
It was entertaining to read and It feels that the world of the character's is well developed and thought out.
I read the first 3 chapters and now want to see where the story is going. I think that young adults would find this engaging and there are some aspects that would resonate well.

I have added it to the watchlist and it gets high stars from me.

Dr Hawke (The Reluctant Adventures of E.Q.)

bjack wrote 117 days ago

Your writing is lively and draws me in as a reader! Love your verbs and the occasional one-sentence paragraph. when I get time, I'll definitely put this on my list of must reads! www.bettyjackson.net

Baisleac wrote 118 days ago

Great review. I hope it makes it into print!! I will certainly by a copy (and the sequelS).

stearn37 wrote 118 days ago

Hi
Congratulations on the positive review.
Hopefully i will see it in print soon.

John Stearn
Author of Derilium

davebending2 wrote 127 days ago

Hi Lucy,
Just finished chapter eight and realised how quickly i'm rattling through these chapters-always means it's a good read!!
CHAPTER 3-'his vivid dark eyes like flicks of calligraphy'-Very nice description, as is 'to woo the stars out of the sky with his snake-charmer's telescope' again brilliant.
CHAPTER 4-the bottom paragraph-'It was slippy' Did you mean slippy or slippery? Just wondered. Otherwise can't find anything i didn't like etc. More to read tomorrow evening.
Dave B

palynch wrote 128 days ago

Hey Lucy,

I've read chapters 1-8 and it is easy to see why you have done so well on this site. A truly imaginative and engaging story. Arthur and Jinger both grabbed my attention immediately and made me carry on reading through the chapters. Think I might even read the whole thing!

Patrick Lynch
The Spirits in the Shadows

Lyn4ny wrote 133 days ago

Hey Lucy,

I only read chapter one here but think this is a truly original piece and can't wait to come back for more. It stands alone and is outstandingly creative in nature. This is witty, clever and Arthur is just one-of-a-kind! Best of Luck to you but I know that you don't need any because you are already a hit on here!

-Lyn
NO REAL ESCAPE to my Nirvana
-Surviving Manic Depression- My story & The Real Truth to Managing It

Seringapatam wrote 141 days ago

Lucy Really good concept for a story. You have a lovely voice hear and I think this is a good book that could do so well. I know there are a few little issues that are mentioned below but nothing that cant be sorted. Great flow, brilliant characters and a great pace to this book. I felt myself drifting off right into the story and before I knew it I found myself as if I was in it. I have scored this high. Love it.
Sean Connolly. British Army on the Rampage. (B.A.O.R) Please consider me for a read or watch list wont you? Many thanks. Sean

Pozzo wrote 141 days ago

Hi - I enjoyed this (see my review below). I was just wondering of you wanted to return the favour and have a look at my offering 'Green Hour'? If you do, though, perhaps you could do me a favour and start at Chapter 7? I know that this is a weird request, but most of my reviews have been from people who have read the first couple of chapters only - there are some twists later on that I would like people to get a feel of...

I hope that you find time to have a little look at it,

Adrian

David Tiefenthaler wrote 142 days ago

How could an old man stop the Murkle Moon? What is the Murkle Moon? What did Arthur do 50 years ago? These are just a few of the questions I have after reading chapter one. What a great start! I'll be reading more and more of this in the days to come. I love it!

Joanne Jacquard wrote 143 days ago

I have dipped into several chapters and very much like what I see. It is now on my watchlist for that valuable moment when I have time to read it properly!

Hoping to get back to you later
Joanne Jacquard
Bryond the Camera

M.C. Schmidt wrote 146 days ago

Wow. This is lovely.

abbydarlaaanne wrote 147 days ago

This is a YARG review.

The plot you've created here is so unusual and original that it's absolutely enthralling! I really like the characters, and I love the way you've peppered the intrigue throughout the story. The dialogue is very natural for teenagers, which I think adds a little authenticity to the characters.
I can't wait to read the rest of this book as it promises to be great!
Abby

CATHERINE SHAW wrote 148 days ago

I have just started reading your book and it looks a delight. What an original idea and you write beautifully. I skipped to chapter seven at one point because of the rave reviews about it. I must say that it touched me because the subtlety of emotion was so beautifully done - very sad. I hope it is published! :)

Bruce Vaughan wrote 151 days ago

Hi Lucy,
I have read several chapters and enjoyed the expereince. I feel it has great potential definitely for the younger readers. I am sure that it be a success.
Bruce Vaughan
A Successful Outcome

Pozzo wrote 152 days ago

This is very imaginative and mostly really well written. The first chapter is intriguing and quirky, while the second plays, successfully, with different voices and registers (although I wonder if the information that it happens 'thirteen years later' could have been given a little more subtly..?) I would agree with another reviewer that Chapter 7 is a highlight. An enjoyable read - one with which to persevere.

Adrian

karamina wrote 153 days ago

If this isn't the next Harry Potter (I'm sorry if you've heard that comparison a million times) I will be amazed. Absolutely entrancing. You've created a world and I've been reading for so long that my eyes have gone square and I'm slightly surprised to look up and see the real world around me, not your world. Please, please say there's a sequel on the way: I am DYING to know what happens to (ahem, spoilers) now that she's (ahem, more spoilers!). R xxx

ps I have backed you and you'd have seven stars if I could :) x)

sllewis wrote 156 days ago

This is a YARG review!

Seeing as there is a little medal beside your name I was very interested to see why that was and I must admit I'm impressed with your writing skill. There's nothing really I can or would want to pick at in the shape of your craft because it's all well written. I have read up to Chapter Seven where Julia's car is... well don't want to spoil things but you know where I mean!

The format, where you have so far been mixing between Jinger, Arthur and toward the end of my read Julia is different and although in some stories this can be off putting and hard to follow, possibly due to the short Chapters, it doesn't feel out of place too out of place. The length of the Chapters themselves are quite sporadic for me, but then I know short chapters are enjoyed by a lot of readers, this is more of a personal preference and for me I have felt a few times the change of chapter was at the wrong time.

Obviously I haven't gotten very far into your book so to make comments now isn't the best way to give a full reflection but so far it's a bit of a slow burner, every time you've gotten to a point that made me think "here we go - somethings going to happen" you tease and switch. I would have liked to have had a little more action by Chapter Seven but then again, I will happily continue to read because it's clear you're building up to something good. Again - probably just me - but within the first seven chapters there's a few with none or very little dialogue which may have helped me to connect more with the characters in general.

Overall though as I said, you're clearly a good story teller and it's easy to see there's more to be had in this story which WILL make me continue reading. Good job :)

Kristi Dawn Hurley wrote 164 days ago

I only read a bit, but that's all it took to know I liked it. Congratulations on becoming an editor's pick!

Kristi
Casting Shadows

authordonna wrote 166 days ago

Hey Lucy, did you ever hear back from the editor's desk? Are they going to publish? They should:)

Scott Butcher wrote 179 days ago

Hi Lucy,

Another day when the world was supposed to end has just passed, so a really appropriate time to see what you'd created with this book "Jinger Barley and the Murkle Moon".

Lovely sister. Not. Just saving what little I've written while I check out another chapter. Oh, and now I'm up to chapter 6, just like that. Ms Flapp is an interesting character. So is Arthur. I'm waiting for him to name a planet. Still haven't quite worked out this Murkle Moon thing yet - how the town has its own moon. Especially haven't worked out how the near collision with the other moon would have happened. All a bit strange really, and fun. I won't add anything more to this comment. Jinger Barley and the Murkle Moon have had lots of comments already. I just wanted to see what it was all about. Well done Lucy. I'll keep reading for a bit longer before I go to sleep.

Regards Scott Butcher (The Merlin Falcon)

margaret c wrote 185 days ago

Hi Lucy,
I just wanted to thank you for all your help during my time on Authonomy. I have published The Magic Kingdom' on Amazon. I have another one on the go and hope to be back soon. However, is it just me that finds it hard to not only get on the site but to replace my edits etc. I am only asking because someone mentioned a comment on television about how difficult it is. Have a word in someone's ear please.Having said that it is an amazing site and the help and support has been wonderful. Good luck with your writing and have a happy christmas. Margaret C. PS. I liked to think I have also given back some support and encouragement.

Charles Wise wrote 185 days ago

A very interesting first chapter and one to add to my watch list. More comments as I have time to read.

Mary Jane Fahy wrote 187 days ago

Hello Lucy,
Read the first chapter of this book and I'm sure I'll return and read more later. I really sympathised with Jinger being the new girl at school, and the not so popular sister. So well polished, seems ready to go! I've put it on my WL as this is my fave genre.
Well done,
M.J

margaret c wrote 193 days ago

Hi Lucy,
I have just published The Magic Kingdom on Amazon. I wanted to say a big thank you for all your help and support. I have had a few problems on site with putting my new edits and replacing the first chapter. I still can't do it, and I have tried several times. I only wish it was a bit more straight forward. I will hopefully be back with my next book. Good luck with all you do, and a Merry Christmas Margaret C.

Leesha McCoy wrote 199 days ago

Wow, now I know what all the hype is about! Tbh, this is not my kind of book but I was completely drawn into it. Thanks for sharing this.
I'd love to crit you but i can't :-)
Best wishes,
Leesha McCoy - Abriya & Clarence. Becoming Aware. The Urban Paranormal Romance.

Mawdlin wrote 205 days ago

YARG review

I can only echo what has been said previously, a beautifully written piece of work with strong characters and plotting. I like the way you make us feel for Jinger instantly and although she's an outsider she is real enough to be believable. You describe her going to the new school, with all the trepidation that causes, with great sensitivity and the sense of foreboding is also executed expertly. I have read up to chapter 10 but so far it is compelling and makes me want to read more. I like the quirky characters (especially Tabs) can see there's lots of scope for intrigue and plot twists. The only thing I thought a bit odd is how most of your chapters are short and then suddenly there is a long chapter (7 I think) which seemed a bit inconsistent but this is only a minor niggle.

Hoping you get this published soon.

Mawdlin
The Witch's Cauldron

dbprdctns wrote 208 days ago

Love it! You have an incredible book here, it was imposable to put it down! The only critique I have is you might want to adjust your placement of the flash backs. You have Jinger opening the mail pouch in the lobby and being surprised by the contents, then she was suddenly in her dorm room and it wasn't explained what was in the mail until Felix reacted to it. I would put the flashback immediately after she opend the pouch and then move her on to the dorm. Either way you have beautiful writing and I can't wait to reed the next book!

C. G. Spaulding

Jennwith2ns wrote 210 days ago

So . . . I guess I was a little slow to actually be helpful in getting your book to the ED, but congratulations on getting (and staying) there all the same--it's certainly well-deserved. This book is flawlessly written.

evermoore wrote 219 days ago

I hope it's not too late to tell you that I love what I've read so far! Obviously, I'm not alone in my feelings for you already have a medal thingy. (smiles) It brings Harry Potter to mind but then makes you forget he exists. Pretty cool, if you ask me. I am tickled for your accomplishment and certain I will see this one in the window of my local bookstore! Congrats...Linda

celticwriter wrote 224 days ago

Hi Lucy, yeah, I'm a little late when it comes to reads. Congrats on your success! I'm not a critic, just a mere scriptwriter who enjoys a work which pulls one in, grabbing, holding, taking the reader along the journey. You make the genre your own. Would make a movie!

blessings,
Jim

made wrote 227 days ago

I really enjoyed this thank you

Andrea Beauvais wrote 227 days ago

This is an interesting story idea.. very original! I have never read a book where the moon was a character who spoke and especially affected the outcome of the story. Very cool so far. The other comments here are very praising so I know I am in for a treat as I read on.

The raven wrote 228 days ago

Congratulations on reaching the desk. I was glad to have backed your book. With your advice and support I can only hope to reach the same position someday

The Raven

The Buena Fortuna

carol jefferies wrote 229 days ago

A brilliant opening, and Arthur's character is very believable. Your writing is easy to read and very good.

I think your book will do well. It isn't my sort of thing I like to read otherwise I would have read more.

Kind Regards,

Carol

stearn37 wrote 230 days ago

Hi
Congratulations for being selected for review.
From
John Stearn